Updated through the 2008 season
| Series Record | Result of Last Meeting | Date | ||
| Conference | ||||
| Competitors | ||||
| Augsburg | 37-31 | W | 13-3 | 4/4/09 |
| Bethel | 35-10 | W | 5-1 | 5/1/09 |
| Carleton | 45-18 | W | 9-0 | 4/2/09 |
| Concordia | 38-9 | W | 9-0 | 4/22/09 |
| Hamline | 33-13 | W | 5-4 | 5/2/09 |
| Macalester | 47-9-1 | W | 10-0 | 4/9/09 |
| St. Benedict | 31-20-1 | W | 9-2 | 4/18/09 |
| St. Catherine | 49-1 | W | 5-1 | 4/25/09 |
| St. Marys | 31-32 | W | 4-0 | 4/19/09 |
| St. Olaf | 44-21-1 | W | 11-0 | 4/8/09 |
| St. Thomas | 22-47 | L | 3-4 | 5/2/09 |
| Non-Conference | ||||
| Competitors | ||||
| Augusta | 0-2 | L | 5-8 | 1987 |
| Austin Peay | 0-4 | L | 3-4 | 1990 |
| Azusa Pacific | 1-2 | L | 0-8 | 3/30/05 |
| Baker University | 2-0 | W | 12-0 | 1991 |
| Bethany Lutheran | 4-0 | W | 17-4 | 5/3/06 |
| Briarcliffe | 0-1 | L | 3-6 | 3/28/05 |
| Buena Vista | 9-3 | W | 7-1 | 3/24/09 |
| BYU-Hawai'i | 0-1 | L | 0-9 | 2/3/03 |
| Cal Baptist | 0-1 | L | 0-2 | 4/14/99 |
| Cal Lutheran | 0-2 | L | 1-12 | 1995 |
| Cal State-Dominguez | 0-1 | L | 4-8 | 3/24/01 |
| Cal State-San Marco | 1-0 | W | 5-2 | 3/22/09 |
| Calvin | 1-0 | W | 8-3 | 3/23/09 |
| Central College | 1-5 | W | 11-4 | 5/7/09 |
| Chaminade | 1-1 | W | 2-0 | 2/5/03 |
| Chapman University | 1-9 | L | 1-3 | 3/29/05 |
| Chico State | 0-1 | L | 0-5 | 1994 |
| Clarke | 1-0 | W | 10-2 | 5/9/03 |
| Coe | 2-3 | L | 2-4 | 5/18/09 |
| Colby | 1-0 | W | 7-4 | 3/27/06 |
| Colorado College | 0-1 | L | 5-6 | 3/25/00 |
| Columbus | 2-4 | L | 1-4 | 1990 |
| Concordia (NE) | 1-0 | W | 3-0 | 3/11/07 |
| Concordia (St. Paul) | 7-2 | L | 0-2 | 3/31/99 |
| Cornell (IA) | 2-1 | W | 4-0 | 3/26/05 |
| DePauw University | 3-0 | W | 7-6 (9) | 3/26/06 |
| Eastern Oregon | 1-1 | L | 4-5 | 3/27/01 |
| Fredonia State (N.Y.) | 1-0 | W | 5-1 | 3/27/06 |
| Georgia State | 0-2 | L | 0-14 | 1988 |
| Grand View | 0-1 | L | 5-6 | 3/21/97 |
| Hawai'i Pacific | 0-2 | L | 0-6 | 2/7/03 |
| Hope International | 2-2 | W | 5-4 | 3/22/08 |
| Huntington College | 0-5-1 | T | 11-11 | 1990 |
| Incarnate Word | 0-2 | L | 4-11 | 1996 |
| Kalamazoo | 1-0 | W | 10-0 | 3/25/08 |
| Lake Forest | 0-1 | L | 1-2 | 5/10/03 |
| Lawrence | 2-0 | W | 13-9 | 3/27/08 |
| Lewis & Clark | 1-0 | W | 4-3 | 3/26/01 |
| Linfield College | 1-1 | W | 4-3 | 3/28/01 |
| Loras | 4-2 | L | 2-3 | 3/13/05 |
| Luther | 5-3 | W | 5-3 | 5/8/09 |
| (Teikyo) Marycrest | 1-1 | L | 3-4 | 3/20/99 |
| Martin Luther | 33-3 | W | 17-0 | 4/29/08 |
| Mass. Inst. of Tech. (MIT) | 1-0 | W | 7-0 | 3/39/06 |
| Menlo College | 2-1 | L | 10-14 | 3/24/01 |
| Messiah College | 0-1 | L | 0-2 | 5/16/09 |
| Midland Lutheran | 0-1 | L | 2-3 | 1991 |
| MSU-Mankato | 2-4 | L | 2-3 | 4/1/03 |
| MSU-Moorhead | 0-2 | L | 4-5 | 1977 |
| Mississsippi University for Women | 0-1 | L | 0-1 | 1988 |
| Monmouth | 0-1 | L | 3-4 | 3/22/03 |
| Mt. Mercy | 1-1 | L | 5-11 | 4/1/99 |
| Nebraska Wesleyan | 0-1 | L | 7-14 | 1991 |
| North Central | 0-1 | L | 4-8 | 3/21/09 |
| North Dakota State | 1-0 | W | 5-3 | 1989 |
| Northwestern (IA) | 0-1 | L | 6-7 | 3/10/07 |
| Northwestern (MN) | 1-0 | W | 11-0 | 1982 |
| New York Institute | 1-0 | W | 9-1 | 1994 |
| Oberlin | 1-0 | W | 8-0 | 3/26/06 |
| Ottawa | 1-0 | W | 1-0 | 3/19/99 |
| Otterbein | 2-0 | W | 9-0 | 3/21/09 |
| Pacific (OR) | 1-1 | L | 3-7 | 3/24/09 |
| Pacific Lutheran | 0-1 | L | 1-10 | 3/27/99 |
| Pitt-Bradford | 1-0 | W | 8-2 | 3/9/07 |
| Point Loma Nazarene | 0-1 | L | 1-10 | 3/10/07 |
| Pomona-Pitzer | 3-0 | W | 9-1 | 3/28/01 |
| Salisbury University | 1-0 | W | 10-4 | 5/17/09 |
| Samford | 0-2 | L | 2-8 | 1989 |
| San Francisco State | 0-1 | L | 7-15 | 1994 |
| Simon Fraser | 0-1 | L | 1-14 | 3/28/05 |
| St. Ambrose (IA) | 0-1 | L | 3-7 | 3/29/98 |
| St. Cloud State | 0-3 | L | 0-7 | 1988 |
| St. Francis | 0-1 | L | 1-7 | 1986 |
| St. Mary's (Texas) | 0-1 | L | 7-14 | 1991 |
| St. Scholastica | 7-3 | W | 9-1 | 4/27/09 |
| St. Teresa | 4-0 | W | 10-0 | 1982 |
| Simpson | 1-8 | W | 2-1 | 3/23/03 |
| Southwest Baptist | 0-1 | L | 8-10 | 1981 |
| Southwest MN State | 1-4 | L | 5-11 | 1987 |
| Taylor University | 1-0 | W | 4-2 | 3/25/09 |
| Tennessee-Martin | 1-1 | L | 0-2 | 1989 |
| Texas Lutheran | 0-4 | L | 4-5 | 2/14/04 |
| Texas-San Antonio | 1-1 | L | 1-3 | 1992 |
| Thomas More (KY) | 1-0 | W | 4-0 | 3/9/07 |
| Trinity College, CT | 1-0 | W | 9-1 | 3/25/00 |
| Trinity University (TX) | 4-1 | L | 7-8 | 2/15/04 |
| Troy State | 0-1 | L | 0-5 | 1988 |
| Tufts | 1-1 | W | 5-0 | 5/17/09 |
| UC-Bakersfield | 0-1 | L | 0-8 | 1994 |
| UC-Davis | 0-1 | L | 1-7 | 1994 |
| University of Chicago | 2-0 | W | 5-1 | 3/27/08 |
| University of LaVerne | 0-2 | L | 1-5 | 3/31/00 |
| University of North Dakota | 1-0 | W | 15-10 | 1989 |
| University of Redlands | 2-2 | L | 1-4 | 3/31/00 |
| UT-Tyler | 1-0 | W | 5-1 | 5/15/09 |
| UW-Eau Claire | 1-8 | L | 4-7 | 3/8/08 |
| UW-La Crosse | 2-2 | W | 2-1 | 3/15/09 |
| UW-Oshkosh | 0-3 | L | 0-4 | 3/29/98 |
| UW-Platteville | 1-0 | W | 12-4 | 3/11/07 |
| UW-River Falls | 1-2 | W | 3-2 | 3/24/07 |
| UW-Stevens Point | 1-0 | W | 5-3 | 5/11/07 |
| UW-Stout | 0-1 | L | 4-5 | 3/22/97 |
| UW-Whitewater | 1-0 | W | 7-1 | 3/29/06 |
| Valdosta State | 1-0 | W | 21-2 | 1988 |
| Valley City State, ND | 0-1 | L | 5-9 | 1980 |
| Viterbo | 1-0 | W | 4-3 | 3/20/04 |
| Wartburg | 1-6 | L | 1-8 | 5/11/07 |
| Washington Univ. | 0-1 | L | 2-3 | 3/29/02 |
| Webster | 2-1 | W | 11-1 | 5/10/09 |
| West Georgia | 1-0 | W | 5-2 | 1988 |
| Whittier College | 1-0 | W | 10-4 | 3/29/00 |
| Whitworth (WA) | 1-0 | W | 8-1 | 327/01 |
| William Penn | 1-0 | W | 2-1 | 3/27/04 |
| William Woods (MO) | 0-3 | L | 4-7 | 3/25/01 |
| Winona State | 6-5 | W | 8-6 | 1987 |
| Williams | 1-3 | L | 1-2 | 3/29/00 |