The four-team MIAC Tournament was initiated in 1986 for the 1986-87 season. Since that time, it has become one of the most entertaining and intense Division III post-season tournaments in the country. The tournament expanded to five teams in 2002-03. Every year, there is a fierce battle during the regular season to see not only which team can win the MIAC title, but also who can finish among the top five in the league and qualify for the tournament.
| 1986-87 |
| Semifinal |
St. Mary's |
2 |
St. Thomas |
4 |
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Mary's |
8 |
St. Thomas |
7 |
At St. Mary's |
| Semifinal |
Concordia |
3 |
St. John's |
3 |
At Concordia |
|
Concordia |
9 |
St. John's |
3 |
At Concordia |
| Final |
Concordia |
3 |
St. Thomas |
4 |
At Concordia |
|
Concordia |
4 |
St. Thomas |
2 |
At Concordia |
| After That? Concordia went on to lose to Bemidji State 3 - 1 in the first game, and lose 8 - 6 in the second game of the NCAA Quarterfinals. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1987-88 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
5 |
Gustavus |
3 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
7 |
Gustavus |
4 |
At St. Thomas |
| Semifinal |
St. Mary's |
9 |
St Olaf |
1 |
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Mary's |
7 |
St. Olaf |
4 |
At St. Mary's |
| Final |
St. Mary's |
6 |
St. Thomas |
3 |
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Mary's |
1 |
St. Thomas |
8 |
At St. Mary's |
| After That? St. Thomas went on to lose to Bemidji State 5 - 1 in the first game, and lose 3 - 1 in the second game of the NCAA Quarterfinals. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1988-89 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
3 |
Augsgurg |
0 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
6 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
| Semifinal |
St. Mary's |
4 |
Gustavus |
1 |
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Mary's |
6 |
Gustavus |
2 |
At St. Mary's |
| Final |
St. Thomas |
2 |
St. Mary's |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
3 |
St. Mary's |
8 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? St. Mary's went on to lose to Bemidji State 5 - 4 in the first game, and lose 7 - 2 in the second game of the NCAA Quaterfinals. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1989-90 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
5 |
St. Mary's |
4 (OT) |
At St. Thomas |
|
Gustavus |
8 |
Concordia |
6 |
At Gustavus |
| Final |
Gustavus |
3 |
St. Thomas |
1 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? Gustavus went on to lose to Mankato State in a NCAA Quarterfinal series as they lost the first game 4-1 and tied the second game 2-2. St. Thomas also advanced to the NCAA Quarterfinals losing to UW-Stevens Point with a 4-4 tie in the first game and a 3-0 loss in the second game. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1990-91 |
| Semifinal |
Gustavus |
4 |
St. Mary's |
3 (OT) |
At Gustavus |
|
St. Thomas |
2 |
St. Olaf |
1 |
At St. Thomas |
| Final |
Gustavus |
7 |
St. Thomas |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? Gustavus went on to lose to Mankato State in a NCAA Quarterfinal series as they tied Mankato State 4-4 in the first game and lost 7-2 in the second game. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1991-92 |
| Semifinal |
Gustavus |
4 |
St. Mary's |
|
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Thomas |
6 |
St. Olaf |
3 |
At Augsburg |
| Final |
St. Thomas |
6 |
Gustavus |
4 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? St. Thomas went on to lose to UW-Stevens Point in a NCAA Quarterfinal series as they defeated UW-Stevens Point 4-3 in the first game, lost 4-2 in the second game and lost 1-0 in the mini-game. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1992-93 |
| Semifinal |
Gustavus |
5 |
St. Mary's |
|
At Gustavus |
|
St. Thomas |
10 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
| Final |
Gustavus |
4 |
St. Thomas |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? Gustavus went on to lose to UW-River Falls in a NCAA Quarterfinal series dropping the first game 5-2 and the second game 4-2. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1993-94 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
5 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. John's |
3 |
St. Mary's |
2 (OT) |
At St. John's |
| Final |
St. Thomas |
8 |
St. John's |
3 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? St. Thomas went on to lose to UW-Superior in a NCAA Quarterfinal series as they tied the first game 3-3 and lost the second 5-1. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1994-95 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
4 |
Gustavus |
3 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
3 |
Gustavus |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Mary's |
4 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At St. Mary's |
|
St. Mary's |
8 |
Augsburg |
5 |
At St. Mary's |
| Final |
St. Mary's |
5 |
St. Thomas |
4 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Mary's |
8 |
St. Thomas |
6 |
At St. Thomas |
| After That? St. Mary's went on to lose to UW-River Falls in the NCAA Quarterfinal series as they lost the first game 5-1 and the second game 5-3. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1995-96 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
4 |
Gustavus |
2 |
At Gustavus |
|
St. Thomas |
4 |
Gustavus |
2 |
At Gustavus |
|
St. John's |
6 |
St. Mary's |
2 |
At.St. John's |
|
St. John's |
4 |
St. Mary's |
2 |
At St. John's |
| Final |
St. Thomas |
6 |
St. John's |
2 |
|
|
St. John's |
8 |
St. Thomas |
0 |
|
|
(St. John's won mini game 2-0) |
|
| After That? St. John's went on to lose to UW-Superior in the NCAA Quarterfinal series as they lost the first game 6-5 and the second game 7-2. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1996-97 |
| Semifinal |
Gustavus |
8 |
St. Thomas |
5 |
At St. Thomas |
|
Gustavus |
3 |
St. Thomas |
1 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. John's |
7 |
St. Mary's |
5 |
At St. John's |
|
St. John's |
4 |
St. Mary's |
2 |
At St. John's |
| Final |
St. John's |
4 |
Gustavus |
2 |
At St. John's |
|
St. John's |
5 |
Gustavus |
4 |
At St. John's |
| After That? St. John's went on to a third place finish in the NCAA Division III National Tournament. St. John's defeated Elmira 4-2 (following a 2-2 tie) in the NCAA Quarterfinal series. In the Semifinals, they fell to eventual National Champion Middlebury 4-1 and then came back to defeat Norwich 4-3. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1997-98 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
8 |
Gustavus |
5 |
At |
|
St. Thomas |
6 |
Gustavus |
6 |
At |
|
Augsburg |
4 |
St. Johns |
3 |
At |
|
Augsburg |
4 |
St. Johns |
2 |
At |
| Final |
Augsburg |
5 |
St. Thomas |
4 |
At |
|
Augsburg |
4 |
St. Thomas |
2 |
At |
| After That? Augsburg defeated Wisconsin-River Falls 3-2 and 4-3 to advance to the NCAA Final Four. The Auggies were defeated by eventual national champion Middlebury (Vt.) 5-2 and lost to host Plattsburgh State (NY) 9-5 to finish fourth in the nation. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 1998-99 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
4 |
Augsburg |
3 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
4 |
Augsburg |
1 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Johns |
10 |
Concordia |
2 |
At.St. John's |
|
Concordia |
4 |
St. Johns |
3 |
At St. John's |
|
(Concordia won mini game 3-1) |
|
| Final |
St. Thomas |
1 |
Concordia |
1 |
At Augsburg |
|
St. Thomas |
5 |
Concordia |
2 |
At Augsburg |
| After That? St. Thomas tied and then lost to host UW-Superior 5-5 and 3-4 falling in the first round of the NCAA Tournament. |
| 1999-00 |
| Semifinal |
Concordia |
7 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At Concordia |
|
Concordia |
3 |
Augsburg |
2 |
At Concordia |
|
St Thomas |
4 |
St.John's |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
|
St. Thomas |
3 |
St. John's |
2 |
At St. Thomas |
| Final |
St. Thomas |
4 |
Concordia |
2 |
At.St. Thomas |
|
Concordia |
5 |
St. Thomas |
2 |
|
|
(Concordia won mini game 1-0) |
|
| After That? Concordia went on to lose to UW- Superior in the NCAA Quarterfinal series as they lost the first game 3-2 and the second game 4-1. St. Thomas went on to defeat Wentworth- Mass. in the NCAA Quarterfinal series winning the first game 6-0 and the second 10-3. St. Thomas was again victorious in the NCAA Semifinal series defeating Plattsbuagh State 7-1. St. Thomas lost to Norwich 2-1 in the NCAA Finals. |
| 2000-01 |
| Semifinal |
St. John's |
4 |
Concordia |
2 |
At Concordia |
|
St. John's |
4 |
Concordia |
2 |
At Concordia |
|
Bethel |
3 |
St. Thomas |
8 |
At St. Thomas |
|
Bethel |
5 |
St. Thomas |
3 |
At St. Thomas |
|
(Bethel won mini game 1-0) |
|
| Final |
Bethel |
4 |
St. John's |
4 |
At St. John's |
|
Bethel |
3 |
St. John's |
3 |
At St. John's |
|
(St. John's won mini game 1-0) |
|
| After That? St. John's advanced to the NCAA Quarterfinals and were defeated by UW - Superior 4-5 in the first game and 0-4 in the second game. |
| 2001-02 |
| Semifinal |
St. Thomas |
5 |
Concordia |
1 |
|
|
Guatavus |
4 |
Augsburg |
2 |
|
| Final |
St. Thomas |
3 |
Gustavus |
2 |
|
| After That? St. Thomas was defeated in the first round of the NCAA Tournament by UW - Superior 2-1. |
| 2002-03 |
| Play-in |
Gustavus |
3 |
Concordia |
1 |
|
| Semifinal |
St. John's |
4 |
Gustavus |
2 |
|
|
St. Thomas |
7 |
Augsburg |
6 |
|
| Final |
St. John's |
4 |
St. Thomas |
3 |
|
| After That? St. John's was defeated in the first round of the NCAA Tournament by UW-River Falls. |
| 2003-04 |
| Play-in |
St. Olaf |
5 |
St. Mary's |
3 |
|
| Semifinal |
Gustavus |
3 |
St. Thomas |
6 |
|
|
St. Olaf |
0 |
St. John's |
5 |
|
| Final |
St. Thomas |
4 |
St. John's |
3 (OT) |
|
| After That? St. Thomas was defeated in the first round of the NCAA Tournament by UW-River Falls 2-3 in overtime. |
| 2004-05 |
| Play-in |
St. Olaf |
3 |
Gustavus |
2 |
|
| Semifinal |
St. John's |
2 |
St. Olaf |
1 (2OT) |
|
|
St. Thomas |
4 |
Bethel |
3 |
|
| Final |
St. Thomas |
2 |
St. John's |
1 |
|
| After That? St. Thomas defeated St. John's 4-1 in the first round of the NCAA Tournament and went on to beat St. Norbert 3-2 and Trinity 4-1, before falling to Middlebury 0-5 in the NCAA Championship game, resulting in a second-place finish. |
| 2005-06 |
| Play-in |
Gustavus |
5 |
Bethel |
7 |
at Bethel |
| Semifinals |
Bethel |
4 |
St. Thomas |
5 (OT) |
at St. Thomas |
|
St. Olaf |
3 |
St. John's |
2 |
at St. John's |
| Final |
St. Olaf |
5 |
St. Thomas |
1 |
at St. Thomas |
| After That? St. Olaf advanced to the NCAA Tournament where they were defeated 2-1 by UW-Superior in the first round. |