Strategies for Choosing and Narrowing
a Topic:
This exercise needs to be adapted for the subject area and level of
difficulty of the course. It could be used early in the process of understanding
a research task.
Give students hints about how to focus a topic for a particular assignment.
Some of these hints may be useful to them:
-
Make a list of possible focus points for your research. Use class discussions,
texts, personal interests, conversations with friends, and discussions
with your teacher for ideas. Start writing them down--you'd be surprised
how much faster they come once you start writing.
-
Invest yourself in the topic. Try to focus on something that matters to
you. You'll do a better job with a topic that has some personal meaning,
and it will make it much more interesting.
-
Map out the topic by finding out what others have had to say about it.
This is not the time for in-depth reading, but a quick scan of publications
in your general topic area can help. Browse the shelves where books on
the topic are kept and see what subjects are covered, what controversies
or issues have been receiving attention. Search a database or index of
articles on your topic area and sort out the various approaches writers
have taken. Look for overviews and surveys of the topic that put the various
schools of thought or approaches in context. You may start out knowing
virtually nothing about your topic, but after scanning the literature may
have several ideas worth following up.
-
Transform your topic into questions. Do two things you come across seem
to offer interesting contrasts? Does one thing seem intriguingly connected
to something else? Is there something about the topic that surprises you?
Do you encounter anything that makes you wonder why? Do you run into something
that makes you think, "no way! That can't be right." Chances are you've
just uncovered a good research focus. It can sometimes help to literally
write down your tentative topic in the form of a question or set of questions.
-
Draft a proposal for research. Write down what you want to do, how you
plan to do it, and why it's important. You may well change your topic entirely
by the time its finished, but writing down where you plan to take your
research at this stage can help you clarify your thoughts and plan your
next steps.
Then use the exercise below to get them started.
1. Briefly describe your topic.
2. List key words that relate to your topic.
3. Go to the following areas to search for information on your topic
and analyze what you find:
-
PALS catalog
-
Academic Index ASAP
-
Reference Collection
-
U.S. Government Documents database (or MLA, or Cambridge Scientific Abstracts
. . .)
-
Google search engine . . .
(create a list of approaches appropriate for the students' work--ones
you think they should use for their research, or at least be familiar with.)
4. As you examine each resource, write down three things you discovered
about your topic. Add new key words you found your search.
5. Use your list to choose which concepts you want to focus on.
6. Now rewrite your topic in the form of a research question. Write
a memo to your teacher explaining what your question is, why you think
it is important, and what steps you will need to take in order to carry
out your research.